Thursday, February 21, 2008
Daniel Barenboim: Importance of Music
In Israel in Feb 1991, when the sirens sounded because of the missile attacks coming from Iraq, people had to get up twice a night, put on their gas masks, go into sealed rooms and wait for 5 mins to see whether they were to survive. This put tremendous psychological pressure on the population of Israel. And yet, as soon as it was safe to do so, the Israel Philharmonic started playing two concerts a day, at 12 oclock midday and at 3 oclock in the afternoon, because it was not safe enough in the evening. Only 500 people at a time were allowed in the auditorium, and they had to bring their gas masks. There was a real need for music to be played, for the musicians to be able to play and for the audience to listen. For some, it was a way of forgetting the tension of the night before, for others it was a moment to hope, of not thinking of the next night with the inevitable alarms sounding. In every case, it was anything but a superficial form of entertainment
Daniel Barenboim: Importance of history
Daniel Barenboim: Memory vs Recollection
I believe you need to contemplate and recollect at a distance in order to express something in music. The most passionate moment in Wagner's Tristan und Isolde, for instance, can only be expressed after a certain degree of contemplation. Contemplation and recollection are as important to a performing musician as passionate involvement. There is a clear difference in English between recollection, and remembrance or memory. In music and musical performance this is an important distinction. A young man remembers and an old man recollects. Memory is something that immediately comes to your aid, whereas recollection can only come through reflection. Recollecting is an art for which you require skill in the use of illusion. To give a simple example: the sensation of feeling homesick although you are at home. This involves recollection and has little to do with memory. This is very important and creates a lot of problems for interpreters today, since we play so much music from memory. Recollection requires individual effort. Everything in musical performance depends on the power of recollection. In other words, even if you have learned Tristan und Isolde by heart, and know it by heart, and you can feel the white-heat intensity of the music, you must be able to recollect this white heat, not just remember it, and from one performance to another add up the sum of recollections you have.
Daniel Barenboim: Practising
For me, learning to play the piano was as natural as learning to walk. My father had an obsession about wanting things to be natural. I was brought up on the fundamental principle that there is no division between musical and technical problems. This was an integral part of his philosophy. I was never made to practise scales or arpeggios. What was needed to develop my abilities as a pianist was done exclusively through playing the pieces themselves. A principle that was hammered into me early, andwhich I still adhere to, is never to play any note mechanically. My father's teaching was based on the belief that there are enough scales in Mozart's concertos.
I often meet musicians who try to solve certain problems in a technical, mechanical way first, and then try to add the 'musicianship', like cream on top of a cake. The two must be linked from the very beginning because the technical means used to overcome certain physical problems will influence the expression.
I always practise the technically difficult passages first- separately and slowly - so that I learn to control and phrase them. one must resist the temptation to try out the right tempo until one has perfect control at the slower tempo. I never play such passages mechanically with the intention of adding the phrasing later. A technically difficult passage needs to be played more slowly until you learn to control it - but with the right musical expression. To separate the technical from the expressive side in music is like separating the body from the soul.
======================================
One obviously has to work, to train. But 'practising' is such an unmusical word. It is a problem of linguistics. In Hebrew, by comparison, the words art, training and faith have the same root, and I do not believe it is merely a coincidence.
All individuals have different spans of concentration. I have no strict rule myself, such as playing eight hours a day or no more than forty-five minutes. Both extremes are equally counterproductive. I never play a single note when my concentration is no longer at its height, for to do so would be to fall into the trap of playing mechanically.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Saturday, February 02, 2008
Mozart Piano Sonata K576, D major
(this piece is also played by Nodame in Nodame Cantabile (Europe special)
Friday, January 11, 2008
Advice from Jim Brickman

Well, I mean the best advice to any aspiring musician is to just get out there and play, and so many people say, "You know if I just lived in LA or something, I would be discovered," or something, but it's not true. It's really just getting out there. And the problem is that now with things like American Idol, people think that it's, you know, a contest rather than just getting out there and doing what you love to do. And the more you do it, whether it's a wedding or a smokey bar or whatever, you get better and better at it every day that you do it and you get better in front of people. You get more experience and it's really a matter of just getting out there. It's not who you know, it's just... working hard and showing people what you can do in any situation you can find.
When did you write your first song?
I started writing as a teenager. Most of it was imitation. It would be my melodies, but the words would be stolen or grabbed from somewhere else to try and formulate my idea at the time of what I thought a song was. I think that most people would tell you that to be a really good songwriter, you have to have grown a little bit more beyond your teenage years. If you're a songwriter, and you're a teenager, it tends to be more manufactured because it's not about anything. It's not from a place of reality or of experience; it's from a place of being a really good imitator. What I got really good at was I could imitate anything that I heard. I could play an Elton John song or a Carly Simon song, or a Beatles song. So when you start to compose -- first of all, it's not a choice, it's not a decision -- what happens is you sit there and play other people's stuff and you start going, 'I wonder what would happen if I played this instead of that or this chord. I wonder why they didn't go to that note.' It's inherent. It's the same as writing. It's very similar to what you do. You learn from reading, and you learn from imitating, and you learn stylistically how to form certain structures of the way things should be. And all of a sudden your voice takes shape.
JB: There are many moments onstage when I forget that I'm there and get lost in the music. You have to let yourself do that to make the music real. I'm beginning to perform with orchestras, and the other night I played with the Pittsburgh Symphony. It was a performance high because it dawned on me that some of the best musicians on earth are playing my music and bringing it to life, translating it heart and soul. It was surreal. It was high. It was spiritual. It was all of those things.
Sunday, November 25, 2007
Mozart's Sonata for 2 pianos K448
The art with which the two parts are made completely equal, the play of the
dialogue, the delicacy and refinement of the figuration, the feeling for
sonority in the combination and exploitation of the registers of the two
instruments—all these things exhibit such mastery that this apparently
superficial and entertaining work is at the same time one of the most profound
and most mature of all Mozart’s composition
K448 and The Mozart Effect:
http://www.smart-kit.com/s245/how-the-amazing-mozart-k448-can-increase-your-iq-listen-now/
Pablo Casals and Music Magic
Before eating, the old man made way to his piano. With great difficulty he arranged himself on the piano bench. To bring the clenched and swollen fingers on the keyboard seemed impossible.
However, his state changed when he started to play his music, Bach’s Wohltemperierte Klavier. The author states that “The fingers slowly unlocked and reached toward the keys like the buds of a plant toward the sunlight. His back straightened. He seemed to breathe more freely.”
By the time he walked away from the piano he walk straighter, taller and without a trace of a shuffle, as if he has been cured from his illness. In short, his state has totally changed.
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
Tuesday, November 06, 2007
Sunday, October 14, 2007
Glenn Gould [Elyse Mach]
That is not to say that there were not occasional moments- perhaps when I was giving a concert with an esteemed conductor or playing a solo work in an especially fine hall- when some special feeling took hold of me. I wouldn't deny that. But it didn't happen because the audience was there; it could just as well have happened at rehearsal or in a practice session. I can honestly say that I do not recall ever feeling better about the quality of a performance because of the presence of an audience. Indeed, it's precisely for that reason that when I record, I banish everybody from the studio except the people actually working on the recording....But I found that even the presence of one person would make me tend to show off and, to that extent, it acutlaly got in the way of the performance. It meant that I was more concerned with their reaction than I was with what I was doing. Consequently, it simply did not serve the musical end. Now if you multiply that one person by two or three thousand at a large concert, you have some idea as to the extent of my reservations about public performances as an appropriate medium for music making.
===========================================
During those concert experiences I had to project that particular piece to a very large audience in most cases and, as a consequence, I had added hairpins - crescendi and diminuendi, and similar un-Bachian affectations- where they didn't need to be; I had exaggerated cadences in order to emphasize the separation of sentences or paragraphs, and so on. In other words, I was making an unnecessarily rhetorical statement about the music, simply as a consequence of having attempted to project it in very spacious acoustic environments.
In a studio, where the pick-up is close to the piano, you can achieve a very similar effect to that which the listener enjoys at home. The relationship of the piano to a microphone which is, eight feet away is very similar to the relationship between the listener at home and his speakers. There's a one-to-one aspect in both situations. But no such relationship exists when one is sitting on a stage, like the Tchaikovsky Hall in Moscow, and projecting a Bach partita to the first row of seats and to the top balcony simultaneously.
So the result was that the record made in the summer of '57 is a very glib, facile effort, because a series of little party tricks which just don't need to be there had been added to the piece.
==========================================
What is it about Schoenberg's music that attracts you?
I think I was first attracted to it because some of my teachers hated it; advocacy can be a useful weapon in a teenage rebellion. Actually I've always been attracted to music that is in one way or another contrapntal, whereas I'm essentially bored by homophonic music. Indeed, I've often said that I have something like a century-long blind spot with regard to music. ..........
.......
When my recording of the complete Mozart sonatas was released recently, I devoted about 7000 words to explaining why I really don't like Mozart's music very much. And one of the main reasons, certainly, is that it's not especially contrapuntal and worked out, so to speak. When I have to deal with such music, I confess that I tend to emphasize tenor parts to alto parts- anything to give it the semblance of a contrapuntal presence, to give it the illusion of a polyphonic lay-out.
==============================================
What about the format, the representation, for example, of the recital? There are rumours that the recital format is out, or at least is on the way out.
Well I don't go to concerts- I rarely did, even when I was giving them, .... so I can't honestly tell you that such a format has no validity in today's scheme of things. But it doesn't for me, certainly; as far as I'm concerned, music is something that ought to be listened to in private. I do not believe that it should be treated as group therapy or any other kind of communcal experience. I think that music ought to lead the listener- and, indeed, the performer- to a state of contemplation, and I don't think it's really possible to attain that condition with 2999 other souls sitting around. So my strongest objections to the concert are primarily moral rather than musical. But as far as the format of the recital is concerned, I personally don't particularly relish a sequence of the same instrumental sounds all evening, especially if htey're piano sounds. There are, as you well know, many piano freaks. I just don't happen to be one of them. I don't much care for piano music.
You don't care much for the music from the instrument you play? That's hard to believe.
Well, I'm really not hooked on the instrument per se- on any instrument, per se. I'm kind of instrumentally indifferent, I guess. Of course, if I hear a very scintillating performance I get great pleasure from it; I certainly don't mean to say that I don't get pleasure from listening to performances that involve the piano, but I don't get pleasure from performances because they invovle the piano. And I think that that really has laways been true. I've never been a piano buff in that sense.
================================================
What are you like outside the recording studio? What is your lifestyle?
First of all, I can't divorce the studio from my personal life. The recording studio and the kind of womblike security that it gives is very much integrated with my lifestyle. I guess tis' all part of my fantasy to develop to the fullest extent a kind of Howard Hughesian secrecy. I'm a very private person, I think, I'm alone, or quasi-alone, a lot because the recording studio, with its small crew, provides me with the atmosphere that I need to work productively- to make music or indeed, to work on a radio or tv program. I stay up all night mostly. I very rarely go to bed until 5 or 6 oclock in the morning, and it's not unusual for me to hear the headlines on "Today Show" before turning in. I tend to get up around three in the afternoon.
===============================================
What about your views in areas other than music? Your views, for example, on a life hereafter?
I can only say that I was brought up as a Presbyterian; I stopped being a church-goer at the age of about 18, but I have had all my life a tremendously strong sense that, indeed , there is a hereafter, and the transformation of the spirit is a phenomenon with which one must reckon, and in the light of which, indeed, one must attempt to live one's life. As a consequence, I find all here-and-now philosphies repellent. On the other hand, I don't have any objective images to build around my notion of a hereafter, and I recognise that it's a great temptationto formulate a comforting theory of eternal life, so as to reconsile one's self to the inevitability of deat. But I'd like to think that's not what I'm doing; I'd like to think that I'm not emplying it as a deliverate self-reassuring process. For me, it intuitively seems right; I've never had to work at convincing myself about the likelihood of a life hereafter. It is simply something that appears to me infinitely more plausible than its opposite, which would be oblivion.
=====================================================
The term eccentric has been applied to you many times. How do you react to it?
I don't think that my life style is like most other people's and I'm rather glad for that; I think it's in some way integrated with the kind of work that I want to do. As I said previously, the two things, life style and work, have become one. Now if that's eccentricity, then I'm eccentric. If eccentricity consists of wearing a scarf in an air-conditioned environment while recording, or playing with an overcoat on during my stay in Jerusalem, I'm guilty; but those things are organic to what I have to do.
Monday, October 08, 2007
Great conversations: the pianists / Eugene Istomin [video recording]
The way Schnabel used to practice... he rarely practiced the really difficult passages. What he would do is practice the chords in something like the opening chords of the slow movement of the Op. 106.32 And what happened, he practiced them for the balance of sound. And in the end, that's really what the key to a beautiful tone, tone is. I mean, he would practice it until the chord vibrated from it, until the harmonics of the chord started to come out, until the chord sang the way he needed to make it. I mean, what I'm trying to say is, there's a vertical component, which is, you know, how the chord and how the chord vibrates and how the harmonics work in the thing-- and then, of course, there's the horizontal component of shaping the melody. If one of the notes sticks out too much, that sounds like banging. I mean, if you do it wrong. Also, when playing a chord, if you do this [gestures], just play all the notes equally, it's, it tends to be disagreeable. You have to use it only for a special effect. Can I add one small thing, which is that, I mean, what most people mean by a beautiful tone is that you bring out the melody and you use the pedal. And I mean, that's what a lot of teachers do. And I mean, to a certain extent, for a good deal of music, this is a good idea. But the whole, the way music is taught, not only in this country but around the world, which is that you use the same kind of sound for Bach, Beethoven, Mozart, Haydn, Boulez, Debussy, you know, Chopin. It becomes ridiculous. I mean, there should be a different sound for each composer.
The wonderful thing, the problem, I think, or one of our challenges is: Music is a horizontal activity, and yet it's the piano, the unique instrument that produces horizontal activity through a totally vertical, totally vertical activity. Violin: horizontal. Blowing air, from piccolo to tuba, is horizontal, in a sense. Putting down 88 keys is totally vertical.
ROSEN:
We all come from families which were immigrant families, too. I mean, there's the second displacement, in other words, that we came from families that were displaced. It's what I said, that-- now, actually, most of the students in conservatories like Juilliard, they come from displaced families from Korea and Japan, and they're an entirely different-- the tradition hasn't changed. I mean, what happens is that music for immigrant families, classical music had a certain prestige, it was a way of sort of arising in society, and we were encouraged by our parents, and, you know, "my son, the pianist," or, instead of saying "my son the doctor" or "my son the nuclear physicist." And so that was a help. And that basically, there was, this is important, I think, for people to understand-- there was a whole transference of the European tradition not just in music but in everything: in nuclear physics, in mathematics. I mean, after 19...after Hitler, after 1938 and the Russian Revolution, there was an enormous transference, migration, of intellectuals from Europe into America. And I know American musicology was created at that time, and American pianism of a very special kind. Otherwise, before that, Americans had to go to Europe and study. Now, the European professors came and taught, and taught us here, and that was a big thing.
Monday, August 27, 2007
Thursday, April 26, 2007
Lynn Harrell - Comparing cello to a singer

Certainly. It's my favourite subject. I think when people hear string playing and they like it, they're moved by it, it's because the string player has a sense of making the string instrument sound and speak and sing like a singer. So there are aspects of singing and speaking that are things we should try to copy and emulate.
...I sense those things and the connections of a good singer to playing a string instrument in a vocal way.
The variety of consonants in language, and the variety of colour of vowels - from the difference in vowels in French, German, Italian, they're just so many colours. The beginning of a breath should sound different than the end of a breath because if it sounds the same it's not a living breathing, alive animal. Sometimes that's extended so a string player is bound to just hold a note and its kind of an abstraction. And vibrato is a natural function of singing, so sometimes you vibrate on a string instrument very fast like a soprano, or sometimes very slowly like a bass singer. Of course when you vibrate very slowly and you're playing in the high register, it just sounds like a very fat over-the-top Wagnerian soprano who should've stopped singing twenty years ago. Which is of course funny. We all think of that as funny. So I can make people laugh by demonstrating (and he does that here, singing… "ooohhh") kind of vibrato. But it's appropriate in certain very low notes, because that's what happens with the bass singer down in the very deep register, where it vibrate much more slowly.
So there's breath, there's colour, there's articulation, and there's rhythm. The notation of music is divided mathematically by twos and threes. But there's a lot in between a two and a three. There's a lot in between that. And of course, there is in language and speech and poetry, there's sense that we can alter, with an educated guess, a classical rhythmic function much like in the La Mer (which was being rehearsed next door, and he demonstrates with notes from more vibrant to languid styles rhythm).
Tuesday, April 24, 2007
Piano Trek
Thursday, April 19, 2007
Wondrous Strange: The Life and Art of Glenn Gould

"There is no excellent beauty that hath not some strangeness in the proportion"
~ Sir Francis Bacon
Gould was emotionally reticent even in infancy. He never cried; he hummed instead.
His private motto: "Behind every silver lining there's a cloud"
"My ability to work varies inversely with the niceness of the weather."
He identified himself as a Nordic man, and all things southern and Mediterranean were anathema to him: sunshine and blue skies, spicy food, physical exertion, easy sensuality, emotional openness, Italian opera. He hated bright colours, and equated red with violence; at the age of four or five he flew into a tantrum when someone gave him a red fire engine. His favourite colours were "battleship gray and midnight blue" and he loved black and white movies, including war movies, ....
When he was eight, is parents took him to wee Walt Disney's Fantasia, and he hated its "awful riot of colour" as he recalled years later. "I went home depressed, feeling faintly nauseous, and with the first headache I can remember".
His hands were naturally agile and flexible, and he instinctively guarded them. Even as an infant he would pull them away or turn his back if someone threw or rolled a ball at him. Once, when he was just weven or eight, Jessie Greig asked him to join in a game of marbles. He wanted to play, but when he put his hand down and found the ground cold, he withdrew it at once, and said "I'm afraid I can't".
Gould's first name is frequently misspelled as "Glen",..... and Gould himself used both spellings interchangeably throughout his life. In fact, it is difficult to find a specimen of his signature which a second "n" is clearly discernable. To his record producer Andrew Kazdin, Gould offered a lame explanation: he had discovered early on that if he started to write the second 'n' he would be unable to stop and would end up writing three 'n's.
The organ, Gould later said, gave him a taste for Bach and other early music, and had a profound influence on his piano style. It taught him to "think with his feet", which led to a fondness for bringing out basslines (he was also left-handed, incidentally); taught him to "think of music as being played by three hands - the feet acting as the third hand," which led to a passion for counterpoint unusual among pianists; and it taught him not to pound the keys but to develop a technique based on "the tips of the fingers," to make expressive nuances through slight shifts of tempo instead of dynamics, both of which encouraged his clean, "upright" clearly articulated piano playing.
Arthur Rubinstein was once asked on television what he would wish for if he were given a second chance at life; he replied, " to be born with Glenn Gould's hands."
And there is the testimony of colleagues like Jaime Laredo, who recalled that he was open-mouthed as he listened to Gould play transcriptions between takes in their recording sessions; he thought Gould's technique superior to that of any other pianist.
"He really did have a magnificent technique," Charles Rosen said. "He could have developed terrific octaves quite easily if he'd wanted to. he just didn't want to."
In an interoffice memo from 1981, a Steinway and Sons employee referred to Gould as the one pianist of his generation with "complete tonal command" - comparable to Horowitz - and more than one critic and fellow musician considered his technique to have been perfect, perhaps the greatest of the age.
Still, to acknowledge that Gould could have played Chopin's etudes or Liszt's B-minor sonata or the Rach3 does not mean that he was physically (never mind temperementally) suited to making a career of such music.
=======================================
"I don't want to think too much about my playing or I'll get like that centipede who was asked which foot he moved first and became paralysed, just thinking about it."
=======================================
Glenn's take on his father's relationships, which I believe is spot on in general.
not appropriate for a person to change their spots so radically for the sake of another person
all relationships are addictive - just as much as alcohol or tobacco
one develops what one thinks of as an intense need to be with a particular person, to translate all your activity, everything that you do in the course of a day, and while that may be a fascinating exercise, it's also exhausting and it has one other great disadvantage - that it distracts you from contemplation, from looking inward, to really meditate upon the shape of your life - one doesn't do that (in a relationship) because one thinks one is starting one's life. When a relationship is new, there's a much greater intensity.
=======================================
Gould and Yamaha
He was testing Steinways as late as May 1981, but never found one to replace his old friend (CD318) permanently, not even instruments which has served artists like Rachmaninov and Horowitz. As always he found the new Steinways, especially the American ones, ranged from "terrible to pathetic" in tone or action or both, and he was not the only Steinway artist to complain at this time: the 70s is generally considered to have been the low point in the company's history.
He tested other pianos - German Steinways, Bechsteins - and finally defected to Yamaha. He first tried a Yamaha ...... and was deepley impressed by the piano's action, which had the responsiveness and the minimal aftertouch he craved. He also liked he intimacy, clarity and brightness of Yamaha's tone, and though he did not consider the sound completely satisfactory - he found the bass unfocused - he knew he could work with it.
===========================================
"The Wars" soundtrack
.... the most important classical theme is that of Brahm's tender Intermezzo in E-flat major, Op.117 No.1, which Gould called "Rowena's Theme". When it first appears in the film, it is associated with Robert's beloved, disabled sister Rowena, who dies before he goes off to war - according to Nielsen and Philips, Gould developed one of his obsessive adolescent crushes on Rowena, and was for a time watching one of her scenes every day. Brahms, incidentally, noted that the piece was based on a Scottish folk song, "Sleep Softly, My Child". The theme is woven throughout the score. In its original key, it is assoc with images of farewell, longing, remembrance; Gould wrote, "If you want the musical-mystical-metaphorical significance, E flat major is a key which composers have frequently assoc with the idea of resurrection (he was probably thinking of Mahler's 2nd symph). The theme also appears in Eflat minor, usually in a hauting version for one or two choirboys when someone dies. The theme hovers over the score like the Angel of Death. The score is in fact unified harmonically, with E flat (major and minor) as principal key. The most important Hymn, "Abide With Me" appears in E flat, and when Gould needed a new theme for the sequence involving Harris's ashes he chose Brahm's dark Intermezzo in Eflat minor, Op 118 No6.
==========================================
Gould as conductor
..... wearing layers of shapeless dark jackets, flannel shirts and pants (plural) despite the summer's heat, and carrying a large, gree plastic garbage bag containing his musical score, notepads and paraphernalia.
Wholly dedicated to the music at hand, Gould was not interested, like so many conductors, in matters of power and personality, and so came across unpretentious.
"What struck me the most about my encounter with Glenn was his unfailing politeness and encouragement to the musicians. He was animated, resourceful, inspiring and sympathique throughout. He did his best to make us all feel like partners in the endeavour rather than sidemen to his maestro. We were all on a first name basis. In fact, he had taken time to commit everyone's name to memory before meeting us, and he made sure to shake everyone's hand at the end of the final session, something none of us expected." ~Timothy Maloney, clarinetist
============================================
Gould on Pedalling
"We are not trying to sacrifice in the piano what the harpsichord did not have, but rather to create an impressionistic effect of what the harpsichord did have."
============================================
"I'm not anti-social, but if an artist wants to use his mind for creative work, then self-discipline, in the form of cutting oneself off from society, is a necessary thing."
"These aren't personal eccentricities, they're simply the occupational hazard of a highly subjective business"
"I don't go to concerts, sometimes not even to my own!"
"The greatest of all teachers is the tape recorder"
=
Monday, April 16, 2007
The Art of Possibility
You need a "catchy" catchphrase, so that you can recall them instantly when the time comes.
Once you are in the habit of using them, these practices will reliably land you back in the boat, reoriented in a universe of possibility.
1. It's All Invented
A shoe factory sends out 2 marketing scouts to Africa to study the prospects for expanding business. One sends back a telegram saying:
SITUATION HOPELESS. NO ONE WEARS SHOES
The other writes back triumphantly:
GLORIOUS BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY. THEY HAVE NO SHOES.
We perceive only the sensations we are programmed to receive, and our awareness is further restricted by the fact that we recognise only those for which we have mental maps or categories.
Rich, free and compassionate.
"no" less personally, and ourselves less seriously, we might hear something else.
Saturday, March 31, 2007
Lili Kraus
http://www.bach-cantatas.com/Bio/Kraus-Lili.htm Wednesday, March 28, 2007
Glenn Gould Hall of Fame
http://www.stim.com/Stim-x/0896August/Sparky/gould.html
Glenn Gould: The Man by Jessie G. Greig
http://www.rci.rutgers.edu/~mwatts/glenn/jessie.html
Writings and Works, etc by and about Glenn Gould
http://www.rci.rutgers.edu/~mwatts/glenn/articles.html
Monday, March 26, 2007
The Cliburn: "Encore! with James Conlon"
Being: existing, incarnating, acting
Playing: pretending, simulating, recreating
Is it to be? Or to play?
Do I play the music? Or am I the music?
Do I become the music? Or do I just play the music?
As an interpreter, there is a constant dynamism between just identifying with the music, becoming spiritually at one with the music and at the same time just playing it, just doing it.
We need to feel identification, we do identify with the composition. We make it our own, we speak of it, making it our own. First of all you practice to a point where you have it "in your hands" and the time that it takes to do that you develop an emotional relationship, as if you had been conversing with that piece, as if that piece had been talking to you, and you're talking back to it.
So you have the illusion that that piece belongs to you, these are words, you hear these things said, "that's my piece", or "that's his piece" or "that's her piece".
I prefer to think of it as the interpreter, having surrenderred his or her ego to the piece, so that the piece can flow into your own person as fully as possible. So naturally, at that moment, you feel that you are a part of that piece, you are that piece and you feel yourself disappear into that piece.
Now, does that make a good performance, or does that make you a good performer?
The answer is no, it's not enough. Because at the same time, you have to have enough distance from your experience of the piece in order to actually execute it. You still have to play the notes, you may miss some, that's ok, but you still have to play them.
This is an illusion that we have, however, when we perform a piece of music to which we identify, because we have, at that moment, the impression that we are at one with the composition, at one with the composer, and in a way maybe that's necessary.
Just the way and actor could imagine to believe he's Hamlet. Certainly he makes us believe he's Hamlet .....
Monday, March 19, 2007

Monday, March 05, 2007
Friday, January 26, 2007
With Your Own Two Hands by Seymour Bernstein
===============================================
GROUNDED
=========
Like how you pivot when you play basketball. If you pivot to the right, you anchor weight of body on right foot, freeing your left foot so that you can pivot right.
When playing piano, the weight of your arm is anchored by means of one finger which instantaneously frees the other fingers.
->Grounded within one hand; eg. hold down thumb and other fingers play
->Grounded between hands; eg LH hold down bass octave while RH running passage.
MEMORY
========
"The study of music contributes to the exercise and acumen of the mind"
-Athenaeus
(referring to memorization as one of the many educative features assoc. with the disciplines of music)
Leaps- try practising with eyes closed
If you play too carried away with emotion, feelings were not sufficiently supported by reasoned analysis and playing lacked security. (if suddenly you look at your hands and ask yourself what's next, that will induce a memory lapse) On the other hand, if rely heavily on analysis, lose contact with sublimity of the passage and end up tedious and boring.
Therefore, confront the keyboard in all its shiftings of pattern without ever losing touch with emotional involvement in the music. Only then would you have earned the right and the confidence to look up or away from the piano if you wished. Musical spontaineity can be sustained only by that synthesis of thought and feeling that makes eye contact with the keyboard or even lack of it, immaterial.
Thursday, January 04, 2007
Mark of a great performance
Tuesday, January 02, 2007
Responsibility towards music
With Your Own Two Hands, Seymour Bernstein, pp203-205
To emerge victorious in an activity as demanding as performing requires great courage and a superhuman organization of one's self.
"It is a grave responsibility to love a composer so much as you love Schubert. You have no other recourse then but to practise diligently so as to give back this love to others through performing." These words had an immediate lasting effect on my pupil, for they gave him a reason to perform that made all other considerations seem of secondary importance. Responsibility to music, he realized for the first time, had to take precedence over all else - even fear. And by taking up this mantle of responsibility, my pupil was able to confront his own talent in such a way that his fear came to seem trivial to him when compared with his love for music. With this in mind, he was soon able to commit himself to a perormance and prepare for it with the kind of motivation that led him to cope with his fear successfully.
What matters most is that you practise as hard as you need to in order to serve music as responsibly as you can.
Saturday, December 16, 2006
Tuesday, December 05, 2006
Sergei Rachmaninov

Mr Rachmaninov's playing is distinguished by clarity. His dissection of a composition is not, however, pedagogic.... He is far from being a dry analyst, but he delights in exposing the structure of a work in an eloquent manner. In this he has no rival.
I am aware that my playing varies from day to day. A pianist is the slave of acoustics. Only when I have played my very first item, tested the acoustics of the hall, and felt the general atmosphere, do I know what mood I shall find myself at a recital. In a way this is unsatisfactory for me, but, artistically, it is perhaps a better thing never to be certain what one will do than to attain an unvarying level of performance that may easily develop into mere mechanical routine.
When playing, Rachmaninov would sit almost bolt upright with his head slightly bent, free of all superfluous gestures, quite unlike the prevailing fashion of the times. Everything was made to appear effortless - his ability to sight-read even the most complicated pieces and commit them to memory in a matter of hours was naturally an enormous help. Even the most thunderous passages would be executed principally from the wrist and lower arm, hardly engaging the muscles of the back at all, resulting in a uniquely clear, yet pearly sound quality. He would retire as he emerged, with a shyness and humility that perhaps exerted the strangest fascination of all.
Rachmaninov felt that every piece had its own peculiar nerve centre around which the rest gravitated. It could be a certain change of chord, the climax of a melody; it might be loud or quiet, fast or slow. Yet if he failed to make this magic moment register properly, he felt that the rest of the work had become utter nonsense. He insisted that it was his own work on composition that gave him this special insight into the inner workings of the composer's mind. Indeed, each and every one of his own works possesses this focal point, some more obviously than others.
=======================================================
Joseph Hofmann's tribute to Rachmaninov:
Rachmaninov was made of steel and gold;
steel in his arms, gold in his heart.
I can never think of this majestic being
without tears in my eyes,
for i not only admired him as a supreme artist,
but i also loved him as a man.
Sunday, November 05, 2006
Rhythm Is It!

“Try to be silent. We work in silence because when we dance,
we have to speak through the body.
So it’s important not to let the energy go out of your mouth.”
The Importance Of Focus
by Royston Maldoom, choreographer, Rhythm Is It!
I cannot plan before I get in because even though I will direct a choreography very much; it starts the moment I'm in the room, with the people. It depends; if the sun is shining, if it's raining, if I had a good night before or a bad one… how they are; it's really impossible to tell. We will just go, do a warm-up, do a lot of work on focus. The majority of the work I do with people is getting them to focus on themselves and how to find stillness. The secret of dance is stillness. In the same way music begins with silence. Without silence you cannot begin to create the music. Painting begins with the blank page, and dance begins with stillness.
So the hardest thing for any group of people who are not used to this work is to find focus. I insist on it. It's not only that it makes our working process easier but also when they are going on stage they have to work for 35 or 40 minutes without speaking. It's a dance performance. That's a very hard thing for any young person today and we have to begin on day one to practice that. It's something they always find very hard and sometimes they find it a little controlling in the beginning. But once they experience it, it is such a good feeling when you discover it, that they become very enthusiastic about it. It will make them look very, very professional when they go on stage.
Monday, October 09, 2006
Sviatoslav Richter on memorizing
By freeing the brain of the useless task of memorizing the music, you can also stop inflicting the same endlessly repeated programmes on audiences - and on yourself.
.............
.............
There are too many masterpieces, and I'm laziness and passivity personified. I simply try to bring a little freshness to the music I play by performing what people don't expect, rather than what everyone else plays. I've worked it out. My repertory runs to around 80 different programmes, not counting chamber works. I'm an omnivorous animal with a large appetite. I've tried to eat all I can, and up until the sixties I continued to take on new works in order to provide myself with a basis on which to keep on changing my programmes. I don't reject a score because i'm not satisfied with what I've done with it in the concert hall. A performing artist doesn't develop in a straight line, it seems to me, but in a spiral. I can be patient and if a piece hasn't worked to my satisfaction, I continue to work on it and play it over and over again.
Thursday, October 05, 2006
Sviatoslav Richter and Heinrich Neuhaus

There's a Russian saying: 'You lack ten roubles, you've one hundred friends.'
Wherever I went, even at the height of the war, I always found a potato to eat. I didn't mind not having a home. I slept wherever people would have me: At Anatoly Vedernikov's, at Volodya Tchaikovsky's, at the home of the mathematician Igor Shafarevich. I felt comfortable everywhere. Above all, however, I was put up by Neuhaus for several years. He was so generous that his pupils could call on him without warning, even at four in the morning. His wife was equally amazing and welcoming. She never slept; if you turned up in the middle of the night, she'd be drinking tea or wine and was delighted for people to come. And she'd say to you:'You've nowhere to sleep? Well, you can spend the night here.' They had a tiny flat.
At Neuhaus's, I slept under the piano.
=============================================================
Emil Gilels was also another one of Neuhaus's students at the Conservatory. But he was a complex individual, had a frightful temperament, was extremely touchy and always sulking. He was pathologically jealous.
With Neuhaus he behaved appallingly badly. Towards the end of Neuhaus's life, he did something dreadful. He wrote to the papers and also to Neuhaus in person, saying that he'd never been his pupil. Everyone in Moscow knew that he had been Neuhaus's pupil and hey were all indignant. When I heard what he'd done, I refused to acknowledge Gilels in the street. Neuhaus was terribley affected by it and died soon afterwards.
=============================================================
(the circumstances surrouding Gilels' death) are appalling. Before setting off on a tour, he went to hospital for a checkup. He was given and injection and 3 minutes later he was dead. It was the Kremlin Hospital. Everyone knows that the doctors there are chosen because of their political background. The result is that, through sheer incompetence, they gave him the wrong injection and killed him.
===========================================================
Neuhaus was of German and Polish extraction, a cousin of Szymanowski. In his youth he had been friendly with Horowitz and close to Artur Rubinstein. He studied in Russia, Berlin, Italy and Vienna where he was a pupil of Leopold Godowsky. He was immensly cultured and widely read in literature, philosophy and the arts. He spoke fluent Russian, Polish, German, French and Italian.
You might have thought his small hands would have had an adverse effect on his playing. But nothing could be further from the truth. He produced a magnificient tone. It's to him that I owe this habit of sitting upright at the piano. He was right, everything depends on this.
Thursday, July 06, 2006
Bernstein on Stillness
It is in our moments of deep quiet that is born every idea,
emotion and drive which we eventually honor with the name of action.
Our most emotionally active life is lived in our dreams;
our cells renew themselves most industriously in our sleep.
We reach the highest in meditation, the farthest in prayer.
In stillness every human being is capable of greatness;
he is free from the experience of hostility;
he is a poet, and most like an angel.
But stillness requires a profound discipline,
it must be worked for,
and it is therefore all the more to be treasured.
~Leonard Bernstein
Bernstein: A Tribute To Teachers
My dear young friends,
Welcome back to Philharmonic Hall. You may think it strange that I have chosen to open this new season of Young People's Concerts with the subject of teachers. After all, aren't these programs always about music? And what have teachers got to do with music?
The answer is: everything. We can all imagine a painter who is self-taught, and maybe some writers too, but it is almost impossible to imagine a professional musician who doesn't owe something to one teacher or another. The trouble is that we don't always realize how important teachers are, in music or in anything else. Teaching is probably the noblest profession in the world -- the most unselfish, difficult and honorable profession. But it is also the most unappreciated, underrated, underpaid, and underpraised profession in the world...........
Monday, June 12, 2006
Leonard Bernstein
========================
... he recognised that the important matter for him then - and for his entire life - was the opening of the mind to the validity of interdisciplinary learning; the best way to understand a problem was the recognition of its relationship to other spheres of knowledge.
' The principal thing I absorbed was a sense of interdisciplinary values - that the best way to know a thing is in the context of another discipline'.
=================================================================
ISAAC STERN on LENNY
--------------------------
'In art, in performance, one of the most difficult things in performing music is - also for him - one of his greatest weakness - the most difficult thing is how to be simple....... Don't interpret, just let music go free like through a glass, a clear glass, a beautiful glass. That's for me the greatest art and that's the centre of the greatest artists' achievements, where everything seems so simple, so right, and just that.
Sunday, April 23, 2006
Isaac Stern on William Kapell
he seemed to walk electrically; it was as if he needed only to touch the piano and it opened up to him. He was a brilliant, explosive virtuoso, a Promethean pianist. During the past two years, his perceptions had matured; his palette of colors and ideas, the inner substance of his music, had grown larger, and he was able to give every greater scope to his performances and develop more and more music of various kinds - classical, contemporary, romantic, impressionistic. There was literally no limit to his talent. He was headed for a major career, not only because of his intrinsic ability as a musician but also because he possessed what I call the "X" factor, the most important quality of personality, describably but unexplainable, that enables the performer to extend across the footlights and mesmerize the audience.
David Oistrakh
Oistrakh answered, "If I stop even for a little while, I'll start to think. If I think, I'll die."
Isaac Stern: My First 79 Years
=============================================================
... willingness on the part of the Russians to listen to another style of interpretation, to be moved not only by the virtuosic, the dramatic, the technically brilliant, but also by the slightest nuances, by a phrase spinning out of a long phrase in a Brahms slow movement, by the fleeting swiftness of Mozart in a rondo, the impressionism of Szymanowski, the elegance, gaiety, and quicksilver brilliance of the Rondo capriccioso of Saint-Saens.
==============================================================
Whenever I studied a work, I would first look at the score to see it in its totality. With Zakin's help at the piano, I would play it through, to acquaint myself with its structure; then play it again, to hear its melodic line. Once I had a clear conception of the work, I would begin to study it technically. When necessary, I would work ten to twelve hours at a stretch, until I felt saturated with the composition.
========================================================
Advice from Dr Leo Mayer on his injured wrist: Play for 10 mins. An hour later, play again for 10 minutes, and an hour later you'll also play for ten minutes. Do that five, six times. Tomorrow, the same thing, but you'll play for 15 mins. The next day, for 20 mins. And then you'll have the rehearsal and the concert.
After he played the entire concerto succesfully: No pain. I flexed my wrist, and it was as though nothing had happened to it. It seemed to have forced itself back into shape because I needed it. That's one of the things the body (or the brain?) can do sometimes, in moments of great need.
"I didn't start worrying about my hands, and I didn't stop playing tennis. Artistic control of one's medium whould never be achieved at the cost of draining the joy of life."
=============================================================
The goals of anybody who thinks about what he's doing change constantly. The more you learn, the more you recognise the absolute inability of any one person to achieve omniscience and perfection with regard to his art. The most you can hope to do is learn what the possibilities are, and then employ your own proficiencies to achieve at least some of those possibilities. And you come to realise that you can never really plumb the entire truth of ideas in music. Tha in essence is the power of music - the fact that the art form is larger, deeper, and far more varied than any single person can divine in his own lifetime - and realising it should give pause to any artist who starts to consider himself all-knowing. We are simply steps in a continuing age-old tradition. When we do something that enhances that tradition, that makes it richer, purer, clearer - then we have done what we were put here for.
===================================================
I chose Bach because there is in his music a pervasive sense of balance, a continuity of deep belief. Whatever he wrote, whether it was a religious choral work or a composition that was purely instrumental, one felt it was permeated with his faith, his devotion to God. For me, his music was always a catharsis; I play it sometimes quietly to myself when I am in a dark frame of mind.
=====================================================
It is astonishing to what degree performing artists are clasped to the bosoms of people everywhere. And if you don't exploit that generosity wrongly, it becomes a tremendous personal, private wealth. I'm grateful to be a musician. Sometimes, when I'm onstage, I feel this wonderful sense of joy at being able to play. I feel blessed. It's extraordinary to have spent a lifetime making people nejoy themselves, and gaining a collective warmth and friendship that has lasted over decades. To be wanted and useful is the ultimate fulfillment for any artist. That's the greatest satisfation an artist can have.
======================================================
The only thread that seems to run through all these artistic accomplishments - and similarly, in other arts - is the imaginativeness of that mind, the ability to see below the surface, to see with clarity what is only dimly perceived by others, and to accomplish with seeming ease what is apparently impossible for the less talented.
========================================================
At each of the music conservatories I visited in Beijing, I heard players with an extraordinary level of talent. They could all play the notes with astonishing dexterity, but they didn't understand the music. They wanted to play the fast, flashy, loud, difficult compositions, display their technical virtuosity. They hadn't had sufficient time or instruction in basic musical values that were part of the old European tradition, and they also thought that technical excellence was a necessary part of good music- making, but that it wasn't everything; I talked to them about emphasising the mind, about playing each note with the ear and the heart.
=========================================================
I remember once telling a group of students that their instruments were there for the music, and not the other way around. Every time you took up your instrument, you were making a statement, the player's statement: a statement of faith, a statement that this was the way you wanted the music to speak through your instrument.
=====================================================
"Let me play the fiddle as well as I can. What is equally important to me is to live like a human being. If I can show people that a musician needn't be a crackpot, that he is fundamentally no different from the next fellow, that music is not a luxury but as natural as reading or arithmetic - if I can do that then I've really done something."
===================================================
"If you ever have any question in your own mind about how a phrase should go, put down the instrument and sing it. Then listen again to how you sang it and where you took a breath, and try to do the same thing with the violin and bow. Eight times out of ten we sing the phrase naturally and properly, and that is what you should try to do with your instrument."
I would urge them not to listen to violin records. I'd say " Listen to a quartet, but with the score. Know the score before you listen, and read the score while you’re listening. Listen to the Budapest String Quartet play the Beethoven quartets – you’ll hear the score being written right in front of your ears. If you want to hear what beauty can be, listen to a great voice singing German lieder. Or listen to a first-rate performance of a Mozart opera. Hear how voices are used, how they change with each word. Notes are our words. And we have to use them in the same way that most people use words when they speak, and as individually as most people, who will sound differently while saying the same thing.”
First of all, learn to look at yourself and say honestly, “I’m not trying to impress the listener; what I really want is for the listener to hear how beautiful is the music the composer wrote. I want the listener to feel how much I love this music. I want to convince the listener that his music is very important to us, necessary for us, as human beings.”
===========================================================
On music and imagination
Your teacher… was quite right in telling you to use your imagination when you are playing music. Whether it should be a literal story or simply an idea of form or content makes no difference really, because, as you study more and more, and read about it and learn to analyse it, you will find it less necessary to have pictures of an event in your mind; rather the music will speak to you in its own language and you will begin to have a dialogue between your understanding of the music and what the composer has written. Whatever you use to excite your imagination in playing or listening is worthwhile, because inevitably it will lead you in the direction of music which is indeed a way of speaking. It does not speak in words, it speaks in images which each of us creates in his own way and it is the only way to get into the inside of the music to find out how many ways there are of speaking the same phrase.
======================================================
Some critics were saying that I might then have been at the very peak of my career had I not devoted so much time and energy to talent scouting and other causes. But they left me unmoved. Perhaps if I had stuck only to the fiddle, only to practicing with the fingers, I might have been playing a little better, I might have accomplished a little more musically- but to what purpose? I hadn’t lacked for public success. So I missed a few notes sometimes. Was that really a big deal? I had the joy of being surrounded by young people who had become world figures and by others who were coming up. I had a whole world of family, and in that sense I was one of the richest men in the world.
Saturday, April 15, 2006
Isaac Stern: Words of Wisdom
=========================================================
A performing artist selects and rehearses repertoire with thought for musical variety, with a wish to display abilities and move an audience, and with the realization that the world of music is enormously complicated in that it is without absolutes - except when what you are doing is wrong, absolutely wrong, wrong in tempo, wrong in ideas, wrong in your understanding of the period in musical history when the work was written, what performance practice was then like; all those things. Rehearsing and practicing, you have to learn what the variables are. Most people do not stop to think that the words "piano", "forte", "mezzo-forte", "mezzo-piano" - that is, soft, loud, half-loud, half-soft - mean nothing in themselves. Each of these indications is simply in relation to the sound that preceded it; the kind of piano or the kind of forte that one plays or uses depends almost entirely on where it comes in the body of the work that you're learning or performing. And the relationship between the quality of sound and the amount of sound has to do with the control and understanding by the performer of the composer's total concept. You learn that when you play the first note of a composition, you must already understand where you expect yourself to be when you reach the final note of that movement, if it is a three- or four-movement work; you must know the tonal, harmonic, and tempo relationships among the movements to make a work hold together throughout its entirety, from the first note to the last.
And you remember the performances of the same work by many great artists, how differently they sounded - and yet all correct. How can music be so differently performed and yet remain correct? Because as the performer grasps the totality of the composition, he gauges the amount of sound and speed required by the work against his own skills with tonal and volume pressures and technical fleetness, so as to enable him to create feelings and ideas that will make difficult passages seem easy. In every fine performance there is a sense of inexorable logic that forces you to say, "Well, of course, that makes absolute sense. It's clear that's the way it should be." Then you'll hear someone else do it differently, and you'll say the same thing. Beyond the necessary acquired knowledge of the instrument and musical history, every artist also has a very personal and indefinable symbiosis with his instrument, be it violin, piano, cello or his own vocal cords. As he plays, he hears the composition in his or her own very special personal voice. Every great artist has a distinctive interpretive strength. That is what one searches for through all of one's life: uniqueness and simplicity. The single most difficult responsibility of a performing artist is to know how complicated, how interwoven, how difficult a work is - and how to get it to sound simple and inevitable.
===========================================================
Mr. Stern himself described his style of play as like the "natural rise and fall of the human voice. . . . You sing in your head, and you play what you hear."
Tuesday, April 11, 2006
Isaac Stern
Two things are necessary for a life in music; a clear idea of what you want to be, and the arrogance to pursue it. You can't walk onstage and say to the public, "Excuse me, I'm here." You must believe in yourself and make immediately clear to everyone, "I'm going to play, Listen!"
For me, the art of making music is a highly personal affair that involves the performer, the instrument, and the public. It's all too easy to be ignorant, or feign ignorance, of basic rules of music and to say or think, "This is the way I feel, I will do whatever I like, I don't need to recognise the boundaries of good taste or know the historical development of musical composition or have some rudimentary idea of the history of musical performance. " But to abide by the strict disciplines of music and, accepting those limitations, develop an individual voice; to become perceptive and honest; and above all, to recognize how to convince the listener - not to go to the listener, but bring the listener to you - that is the mark of musical artistry
Thursday, April 06, 2006
John Carewe
......... one of the essential things about the analysis we had been doing together was that once you had done it and it had guided your instincts then you had to forget everything and let it come through your subconscious. You're not teaching the orchestra or the audience what you've learned in analysing the piece! Your analysis tells you how the music goes, and then you've got to put it across.

